- The traditional Indian plate was built on whole grains, millets, dal, vegetables and fibre, not on refined flour and sugar.
- What has changed is how we eat Indian food today: more maida, white sugar, deep frying, packaged snacks and bigger portions.
- ICMR-INDIAB found diabetes in 11.4 percent and prediabetes in 15.3 percent of Indian adults, which points at lifestyle, not at dal and roti.
- Ayurveda judges food by quality, quantity, timing and digestion, a framework that fits the modern evidence well.
- Small swaps in your own kitchen matter more than switching to a foreign diet.
"Your every illness comes from Indian food." If you have spent time on health reels or read wellness ads over the last few years, you have heard some version of this line. Dal is "too many carbs", roti is "the enemy", and the solution on offer usually comes in a packet with a foreign label.
The short answer: no, traditional Indian food is not what is making us sick. The way most of us eat Indian food today, with refined flour, white sugar, deep frying, packaged snacks and oversized portions, very likely is. That distinction is the whole point of a short video Dr. Aditya Kunal made on this subject, and this post is built on his argument, expanded with research and the Ayurvedic view of food.
The narrative Dr. Aditya Kunal is pushing back against
In his video, Dr. Aditya Kunal points out that the "Indian diet is the root of disease" story has been repeated loudly by media houses and many companies in recent years. His response is blunt: it is completely wrong. He then makes three observations that are worth slowing down on.
- Refined white sugar is a newcomer. India has made gur (jaggery) and khand for a very long time, and the English word sugar itself traces back to the Sanskrit sharkara. But cheap factory-refined white sugar in every kitchen, every chai and every packaged snack is a modern, largely post-colonial pattern.
- Junk food was not part of the Indian kitchen. Chips, cola, instant noodles and frozen snacks are recent arrivals.
- The traditional plate was rich in millets, fibre, salad and green vegetables. Think of bajra and makka roti in winter, sattu, seasonal saag, kachumber, dal and buttermilk.
His conclusion, in his own framing: the way we consume the Indian diet today can certainly be a reason for disease. The way we used to consume it, not at all.
What a traditional Indian plate actually looked like
There is no single "Indian diet". A meal in Patna looks nothing like one in Chennai or Jaipur. Still, most regional food traditions share a structure, and that structure is surprisingly close to what modern nutrition science recommends.
| Element | Traditional pattern | Common pattern today |
|---|---|---|
| Grain | Millets (bajra, jowar, ragi, kodo), hand-pounded rice, chakki atta | Polished white rice, maida in bread, biscuits, naan and momos |
| Protein | Dal, chana, rajma, sattu, curd, some meat or fish by region | Smaller dal portions, protein often missing at breakfast |
| Vegetables | Seasonal sabzi, saag, raw salad, chutneys | One small sabzi, often deep fried or swimming in oil |
| Sweet | Gur, fruit, occasional festival sweets | White sugar daily in tea, cold drinks, packaged sweets |
| Fat | Small amounts of ghee or mustard oil, fresh | Refined oils, reused frying oil, vanaspati in snacks |
| Movement | Walking, farm work, housework, cycling | Desk work, two-wheelers, screens |
Look at the right-hand column. None of it is traditional. When people say "Indian food made me diabetic", they are usually describing the right-hand column and blaming the left.
A note on Bihar's own food
Bihar is a good example. Sattu, made from roasted chana, is high in protein and fibre. Litti with chokha pairs a whole grain with roasted vegetables. Makhana, local greens and seasonal fruit fit naturally into a healthy plate. The trouble starts when the same household adds samosa and jalebi as a daily breakfast, sweet tea four times a day and a cold drink with lunch. Read more in our post on Indian foods for gut health.
What the numbers say about India's health right now
The largest national survey on metabolic disease, the ICMR-INDIAB study published in The Lancet Diabetes and Endocrinology in 2023, examined more than 1.1 lakh adults across the country. It found diabetes in 11.4 percent of adults, prediabetes in 15.3 percent, generalised obesity in 28.6 percent and abdominal obesity in 39.5 percent. Almost every one of these conditions was more common in cities than in villages.
That urban gap is telling. Rural and urban India share the same cuisine. What differs is activity, access to packaged food, sugar-sweetened drinks, eating out and sleep. If dal and roti were the problem, villages would be hit as hard as cities.
The World Health Organization also notes that type 2 diabetes is often preventable, and its advice is simple: keep a healthy weight, stay physically active, eat a healthy diet and limit sugar and saturated fat. Nothing in that list asks you to give up your own cuisine.
Where the modern Indian plate really goes wrong
If we are honest, the drift away from the traditional plate has happened in a few specific places.
1. Too much polished rice and refined flour
A meta-analysis in the BMJ in 2012 pooled cohort studies on white rice and found that people in the highest intake group in Asian populations had a higher risk of type 2 diabetes than those in the lowest. That does not make rice evil. It does mean that three heaped plates of white rice a day, with little dal or vegetable and no movement, is a risk pattern. Our ancestors ate rice too, but often less polished, with more labour and more vegetables alongside.
2. Sugar in liquid form
Sweet tea, packaged juices, cold drinks and sweetened lassi deliver sugar without fullness. A 2010 meta-analysis in Diabetes Care found that people drinking one to two sugar-sweetened beverages a day had about a 26 percent higher risk of type 2 diabetes than those who rarely drank them. This is exactly the "refined sugar" point Dr. Aditya Kunal makes, and it is backed well by research. We go deeper in does eating sugar cause diabetes.
3. Losing millets
Millets were once everyday grains across India. A 2021 systematic review and meta-analysis in Frontiers in Nutrition found the average glycaemic index of millets to be about 36 percent lower than milled rice and refined wheat, and long-term millet intake lowered fasting and after-meal blood sugar in people with diabetes. Our guide to millets for blood sugar explains which ones to choose and how to cook them.
4. Frying and reused oil
Traditional cooking used fat, but in modest amounts and mostly fresh. Street food and restaurant cooking often reuses the same oil for days. Pakoras and samosas were festival or occasional foods, not a daily evening habit.
5. Eating at the wrong time and in the wrong amount
Late dinners at 11 pm in front of a screen, constant snacking and eating when not hungry are habits the classical texts warned about directly.
How Ayurveda judges a diet
Ayurveda never judged food by a single nutrient. The classical texts describe several factors that decide whether a food helps or harms you. In the Charaka Samhita these are discussed as the ashta ahara vidhi vishesha ayatana, the eight factors of food, which include the nature of the food, how it is prepared, combinations, quantity, place, time, the rules of eating and the person eating it.
Put simply, the same dal can nourish one person and trouble another, depending on:
- Quantity (matra): eating to roughly three-quarters of capacity, leaving room for digestion.
- Timing (kala): eating when the previous meal is digested and true hunger appears.
- Preparation (samskara): soaking, roasting, fermenting and spicing make grains and pulses easier to digest.
- Your digestive fire (agni): a strong appetite handles heavy food, a weak one does not. See our post on agni.
- Your activity: the texts link heavy, sweet, oily food without exercise to kapha accumulation and to prameha, the group of urinary and metabolic disorders that includes diabetes.
This framework explains why the "Indian food is bad" argument misses the point. A plate of kheer, puri and sweets after a day of hard physical work during a festival is very different from the same plate eaten daily by someone who sits for ten hours.
Rebuilding a traditional plate in a modern kitchen
You do not need a new cuisine. You need to bring back the structure your grandparents' plate had. Here is a practical starting point most of my patients find easy to follow.
- Half the plate vegetables: one cooked sabzi plus raw salad or kachumber.
- A quarter protein: a full katori of dal, chana, rajma, paneer, curd, egg, fish or chicken as per your practice.
- A quarter grain: millet roti, chakki atta roti, or a modest serving of rice. Rotate millets through the week.
- Sweetness from fruit and small amounts of gur, not from sugar in every cup of tea.
- Buttermilk with lunch, spiced with roasted jeera, instead of a cold drink.
- Early dinner, ideally two to three hours before sleep.
- A 15 to 20 minute walk after meals, the simplest habit for blood sugar.
The six tastes of Ayurveda offer another useful check: a balanced meal includes bitter and astringent tastes too, from greens, methi, karela and dal, not only sweet, salty and sour.
Who should be extra careful
If you already have diabetes, high blood pressure, kidney disease, fatty liver or high cholesterol, diet changes should be planned with your treating doctor, especially if you take medicines that lower blood sugar. Switching suddenly to large amounts of millets or fasting can change your sugar readings, and your medicine doses may need review by your doctor. Never stop or reduce a prescribed medicine on your own because you have started eating better.
Bringing your own plate back home
The real lesson from Dr. Aditya Kunal's video is a hopeful one. The solution to India's metabolic problem is largely sitting in our own food traditions, not in an imported powder. If you want help translating this into a plan for your body, your work hours and your reports, you can book a consultation with Dr. Aditya Kunal, online or in person in Patna. For diabetes-specific support, see the diabetes and lifestyle page.
Frequently asked questions
Is Indian food unhealthy?
Traditional Indian food built on whole grains, millets, pulses, vegetables, curd and spices is not unhealthy. The problem is the modern version, heavy on refined flour, white rice in large portions, sugar, deep fried snacks and packaged food, eaten with little physical activity.
Why do so many Indians get diabetes if our food is healthy?
Diabetes comes from many factors together: genetics, central obesity, low activity, poor sleep, stress and a diet that has shifted toward refined carbohydrates and sugar. Indians also tend to develop diabetes at a lower body weight, so habits matter even more for us.
Should I switch to a Western diet like keto to stay healthy?
There is no need to abandon Indian food. A plate built the traditional way, with millets or whole grains, a generous serving of dal or other protein, vegetables, salad and curd, gives most of the benefits people look for in imported diets, and it is easier to sustain.
Is rice bad for health?
Rice is not poison. Large portions of polished white rice eaten every meal, with little vegetable or protein and little activity, are linked to higher diabetes risk. Smaller portions, hand-pounded or parboiled rice, and pairing rice with dal and sabzi make a real difference.
Is ghee bad in an Indian diet?
In Ayurveda ghee is valued in small amounts. The trouble starts with excess quantity and with reused or deep frying oils. If you have high cholesterol or heart disease, ask your doctor how much fat suits you.
Sources and further reading
- Anjana RM et al. Metabolic non-communicable disease health report of India: ICMR-INDIAB-17. Lancet Diabetes Endocrinol, 2023
- Hu EA et al. White rice consumption and risk of type 2 diabetes: meta-analysis and systematic review. BMJ, 2012
- Malik VS et al. Sugar-sweetened beverages and risk of metabolic syndrome and type 2 diabetes: a meta-analysis. Diabetes Care, 2010
- Anitha S et al. A systematic review and meta-analysis of the potential of millets for managing and reducing the risk of diabetes. Front Nutr, 2021
- World Health Organization. Diabetes fact sheet

