- Eating sugar alone does not cause diabetes, but a high sugar intake, especially in drinks, clearly raises the risk.
- Charaka lists many causes of prameha, starting with "asya sukham, svapna sukham": a life of sitting comfortably and sleeping too much.
- Inactivity, excess weight around the waist, heavy refined carbohydrates and genetics all work together.
- Charaka also names newly harvested grains among the causes; modern evidence on grain ageing is early and limited.
- Avoiding sugar is necessary but not enough; movement, sleep timing and the whole diet matter as much.
"I have stopped sugar completely, so I can't get diabetes, right?" Dr. Aditya Kunal hears versions of this all the time. The opposite worry is just as common: "I ate too many sweets as a child, is that why I have diabetes now?"
Does eating sugar cause diabetes? Not on its own. Sugar, especially in drinks and sweets eaten daily, clearly raises the risk. But diabetes, which Ayurveda calls prameha, has many causes, and the most important one in the classical texts is not sugar at all. It is a comfortable, inactive way of life. This post is built on a short video by Dr. Aditya Kunal on this question, expanded with the classical source and modern research.
Charaka's famous list of causes
In his video, Dr. Aditya Kunal points out that Ayurveda describes many causes of prameha, and the first one is not eating sweets. It is not exercising. He quotes the opening words of a well-known verse from the Charaka Samhita, Chikitsasthana, in the chapter on prameha: "asya sukham, svapna sukham".
The verse lists the causes roughly like this:
- Asya sukham: the pleasure of sitting, a sedentary life
- Svapna sukham: the pleasure of sleeping, too much sleep and day sleep
- Dadhini: excess curd
- Meat of domestic, aquatic and marshland animals in excess
- Payamsi: excess milk and milk products
- Navannapanam: newly harvested grains and new drinks
- Guda vaikritam: jaggery and its products, in other words sugar and sweets
- And, the verse adds, everything else that increases kapha
Look at the order. Sitting and sleeping come first. Sweet things appear near the end of a longer list of heavy, kapha-building foods. As Dr. Aditya Kunal explains, asya sukham, svapna sukham means you prefer an overly comfortable lifestyle: sleeping late, doing no physical activity at all.
Charaka was describing the lives of comfortable, well-fed people more than two thousand years ago. The description fits modern urban India uncomfortably well.
Cause one: the comfortable, inactive life
Why would sitting cause diabetes? Your muscles are the largest users of blood sugar in the body. When they work, they pull glucose out of the blood, even without much insulin. When they are idle for most of the day, sugar stays in the blood longer, the body needs more insulin to manage it, and over time cells respond less to insulin. This is insulin resistance, the soil in which type 2 diabetes grows.
Modern trials strongly support Charaka's emphasis. In the Diabetes Prevention Program, published in the New England Journal of Medicine in 2002, a lifestyle programme aimed at at least 150 minutes of activity a week and modest weight loss reduced the development of diabetes by 58 percent in people at high risk. The World Health Organization's prevention advice also starts with staying active and keeping a healthy weight.
A typical day for many people today: a two-wheeler or car to work, eight to ten hours at a desk, evenings on the sofa with a phone. Even someone who never touches sweets can build insulin resistance this way.
Cause two: oversleeping and late nights
Svapna sukham refers to sleeping too much, especially during the day. Ayurveda considers day sleep heavy and kapha-increasing, except for specific groups like the elderly, the sick and people who are exhausted. In his video, Dr. Aditya Kunal adds sleeping late in the morning to this picture.
Modern sleep research has also linked both short sleep and irregular sleep timing to poorer blood sugar control. The common modern pattern of going to bed at 1 am and waking at 9 or 10 am, with a heavy late dinner, is very different from the early-to-bed routine Ayurveda recommends in dinacharya.
Cause three: sugar, especially in liquid form
Now to sugar itself. Dr. Aditya Kunal is clear in his video that avoiding sugar is essential anyway. It is just not the whole story.
The research is clearest for sugary drinks. A 2010 meta-analysis in Diabetes Care pooled data from over 310,000 people and found that those who drank one to two sugar-sweetened beverages a day had about a 26 percent higher risk of type 2 diabetes than those who rarely drank them. Liquid sugar is absorbed quickly and does not make you feel full, so it adds calories on top of meals.
In Indian terms, that includes:
- Chai with two spoons of sugar, four times a day
- Packaged fruit juices and "health" drinks
- Cold drinks and energy drinks
- Sweetened lassi and milkshakes
- Sugarcane juice daily in summer
Is jaggery a safe swap?
Many families switch to gur thinking it is harmless. Jaggery is less refined and carries traces of minerals, but it still raises blood sugar. Interestingly, Charaka specifically lists guda vaikritam, the products of jaggery, among the causes of prameha. So a traditional sweetener does not get a free pass in Ayurveda either.
Cause four: new grains and refined carbohydrates
The most unusual point in Dr. Aditya Kunal's video is about newly harvested grains, nava anna. Charaka lists them as a cause of prameha, and Ayurveda generally recommends grains that have been stored for about a year (purana, old) for people prone to kapha disorders, because new grains are considered heavy and harder to digest.
Dr. Aditya Kunal mentions that newer research findings also point to a higher sugar spike from newly harvested grains. Here, it is important to be precise about what the evidence shows. A 2026 laboratory study from Japan stored rice flour for six months and found that rapidly digestible starch fell and the estimated glycaemic index decreased after storage. A 2024 review of prameha in classical literature also discusses the historical link between new rice and wheat and the disease. These are interesting signals, but they are early, mostly laboratory findings, not large human trials.
What is well established is the risk from large amounts of refined grain. A 2012 meta-analysis in the BMJ found that higher white rice consumption was associated with a higher risk of type 2 diabetes, particularly in Asian populations who eat it several times a day. Refined flour (maida) in bread, biscuits and bakery snacks behaves similarly.
Practical takeaways that respect both Ayurveda and the research:
- Eat rice in moderate portions, ideally with plenty of dal and vegetables.
- Prefer parboiled or less polished rice where you can.
- Bring back millets and barley, which Ayurveda recommends specifically in prameha. See millets for blood sugar.
- Choose chakki atta over maida.
- If you buy rice in bulk at harvest time, there is no harm in using older stock first.
The causes that are not on Charaka's list, but matter
Modern medicine adds a few factors that ancient physicians could only partly see:
| Factor | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Family history | Type 2 diabetes runs strongly in families. Ayurveda recognised inherited prameha too (sahaja). |
| Abdominal fat | Fat around the waist and liver drives insulin resistance, even at normal body weight. |
| Stress | Chronic stress hormones raise blood sugar. |
| PCOS and pregnancy diabetes | Both increase a woman's future risk. |
| Some medicines | Steroids and certain other drugs can raise blood sugar. Never stop them without your doctor. |
| Age | Risk rises with age, but Indians often develop diabetes in their thirties and forties. |
Notice that most items in this table connect back to Charaka's core idea: too much heaviness coming in and too little movement going out. Ayurveda would describe it as kapha and meda accumulating faster than a weakened agni can process them. The vocabulary differs, but the advice that follows, eat lighter and move more, is the same.
Type 1 diabetes is different
Everything above is about type 2 diabetes, the most common form. Type 1 diabetes is caused by the immune system destroying insulin-producing cells. It has nothing to do with eating sweets, and children with type 1 diabetes should never be blamed for their condition. They need insulin, which is life-saving.
So what should you actually do?
Dr. Aditya Kunal's conclusion is that diabetes can come from many causes, and the answer has to match. A balanced plan looks like this:
- Move every day. Walk after meals, take stairs, and aim for at least 150 minutes of moderate activity a week, plus some strength work.
- Fix your sleep. Sleep and wake at regular times, avoid long day naps, and keep dinner early and light.
- Cut liquid sugar first. Reduce sugar in tea gradually, and replace cold drinks and juices with water, buttermilk or lemon water without sugar.
- Rebalance the plate. Smaller portions of rice and roti, more dal, vegetables and salad. See the truth about the Indian diet.
- Limit heavy, kapha-building foods like excess sweets, fried snacks, heavy milk desserts and late-night curd.
- Get tested if you have risk factors, even if you feel fine.
If you already have diabetes and take medicines, these changes work alongside your treatment, never instead of it. Keep taking your medicines as prescribed and let your doctor review your doses as your readings change.
Looking at the whole picture
Blaming sugar alone is tempting because it is simple. Charaka's list is more honest: diabetes grows out of how we sit, sleep, eat and live. If you want a plan that looks at all of those together, matched to your reports and routine, Dr. Aditya Kunal consults in Patna and online. To understand the classical theory in more depth, read prameha: how Ayurveda understands diabetes, or visit the diabetes and lifestyle page.
Frequently asked questions
Does eating too much sugar cause diabetes?
Sugar on its own is not the single cause, but a diet high in added sugar, especially sugary drinks, is linked to weight gain and a higher risk of type 2 diabetes. Diabetes usually results from several factors together, including inactivity, central obesity, genetics and overall diet.
Can I get diabetes even if I don't eat sweets?
Yes. Many people who rarely eat sweets develop type 2 diabetes because of inactivity, abdominal fat, large portions of refined carbohydrates, poor sleep, stress and family history.
Is jaggery better than sugar for diabetes?
Jaggery is less refined and has small amounts of minerals, but it still raises blood sugar much like sugar. People with diabetes or prediabetes should limit both. Ayurveda itself lists products of jaggery (guda vikara) among the causes of prameha.
What does "asya sukham" mean in Ayurveda?
It means the pleasure of sitting comfortably. Charaka lists it first among the causes of prameha, followed by svapna sukham, the pleasure of excessive sleep. Together they describe a sedentary, comfort-seeking lifestyle.
Is old rice better than new rice for diabetes?
Ayurveda recommends old (stored) grains over newly harvested ones for people prone to prameha, as new grains are considered heavier. Some early laboratory studies suggest storage may change how rice starch is digested, but human evidence is limited. Portion size and what you eat with rice matter more.
Sources and further reading
- Malik VS et al. Sugar-sweetened beverages and risk of metabolic syndrome and type 2 diabetes: a meta-analysis. Diabetes Care, 2010
- Hu EA et al. White rice consumption and risk of type 2 diabetes: meta-analysis and systematic review. BMJ, 2012
- Influence of production area and storage on starch digestibility and glycemic properties of rice flour. J Sci Food Agric, 2026
- Etiopathogenesis and management of Prameha Poorvaroopa (prediabetes), Prameha and Madhumeha: an ancient perspective. Adv Mind Body Med, 2024
- Diabetes Prevention Program Research Group. Reduction in the incidence of type 2 diabetes with lifestyle intervention or metformin. N Engl J Med, 2002
- World Health Organization. Diabetes fact sheet

